How to Keep New Hires From Quitting Before They Even Settle In

👋 Hey, I’m Walt, Welcome to Business, Marketing, & Mayhem - the only newsletter where Business, Marketing, and Coaching collide… in the best way possible.

Thanks for stopping by.

Three times a week, I write about stuff that helps you make more money, whether you’re a business owner, a marketing agency, or a coach looking to level up. Got a topic you’re itching to know more about? Just hit me up - I’m all ears.

Oh, and if you want the exclusive subscriber-only edition (yes, the good stuff), go here:

Here’s something most small business owners never realize until it’s too late:
People don’t usually quit after a year.

They quit in the first 90 days.

And it’s almost never about money, hours, or benefits.

It’s because they never felt like they belonged in the first place.

That’s right. Those first few weeks are when new hires are quietly deciding whether they made a smart move… or whether they should start scrolling Indeed again before the ink on their paperwork dries.

The good news? That’s something you can fix.

Why the First 90 Days Matter More Than You Think

When someone joins your team, they’re not just learning how to do the job. They’re deciding if they want to stay. Every task, every interaction, every conversation is helping them answer one big question:

“Do I actually belong here?”

If the answer is no, they’re already planning their exit - even if they’re smiling through the team lunch.

Where Most Onboarding Goes Off the Rails

Here’s the problem: most small businesses treat onboarding like a checklist.
Fill out some forms. Watch a training video. Meet a few people. Get to work.

That’s not onboarding. That’s paperwork.

The real job of onboarding is to make people feel like part of the team — like they’re needed, valued, and on the path to something bigger than a paycheck.

3 Simple Fixes That Keep People From Quitting

1. Make Day One Memorable
A first day should feel like a big deal. Greet them personally. Have their workspace ready. Introduce them to the team with purpose, not as an afterthought.

2. Give Them a Quick Win
Confidence keeps people engaged. Assign an easy project in week one that lets them succeed fast. That early win sets the tone and shows them they’re already contributing.

3. Talk. Don’t Just “Be Available.”
Saying “my door’s always open” isn’t enough. Schedule real check-ins during those first 90 days. Ask what’s working, what’s confusing, and what they need to succeed. You’ll solve small issues before they turn into resignation letters.

The Bottom Line

Employee retention doesn’t start six months in — it starts on day one.
If you make people feel welcome, supported, and like they’re part of something that matters, they’ll stick around. And when they do, your business runs smoother, your team is stronger, and your hiring headaches start to disappear.

If you want more simple, proven ways to keep your best people longer, grab a free copy of The Employee Retention Guide for Small Business Owners.

It’s packed with strategies that work in the real world — not corporate theory — and it’ll help you build a team that actually wants to stay.